1969: Organizing pastor, Rev. Jack Ewart, resigned. Rev. Robert Bryan was called.
1972: Rev. Robert Bryan resigned. Rev. Robert Walkup was called on Nov. 5, 1972.
1984: Rev. Robert Walkup resigned to accept a position with the Medical Benevolence Association.
1985: Rev. Thomas James Thompson was installed on May 19, 1985.
1995: Rev. Jim Cummings interim pastor from to 1995 to 1997
1997: The Rev. Peter Dembroski installed in 1997.
2007: Pastor Dembroski served until May 31st, 2007 resigning to take a call to Mifflin Presbyterian Church in Gahanna, Ohio.
2007: Interim Pastor Alan Mugler was called effective August 27, 2007, serving until November 23rd, 2007.
2008: Interim Pastor John Harris was called effective February 15th, 2008 and served in an interim capacity until the new pastor was called.
2011: Rev. Laura C. Kelsey was called as Pastor of Hope, beginning her ministry on April 10, 2011.
2015: Rev. Laura C. Kelsey served until February 8, 2015 resigning to take a call to First Presbyterian Church in Pontiac, Michigan.
2015: Stated Supply Pastor David Shelor was called to Hope on July 19th, 2015.
2016: Pastor David Shelor served until March 13th, 2016 resigns to take a call to First Presbyterian Church of Dunedin.
2016:Stated Supply Pastor Vickey ByRode was transfered from Highland to Hope in March of 2016.
2016: Stated Supply Pastor David Hosick was called to Hope in May of 2016.
Both David Hosick and Vickey ByRode retired in May 2017
2017: Stated Supply Pastor Ginny Ellis was called to Hope in August of 2017.
2019: Pastor Ginny Ellis left Hope and Moved to a Church In Tampa in Nov. 2019.
2020: Pastor Bob Hill moved from Kentucky to Hope as our full time pastor in January 2020.
2025: Pastor Greggory Brown was called as our stated supply pastor.